The scene that deals with the morality of living together without the benefit of marriage-
The dialogue between Mr. Manders, who represents the view of organized religion (superstition), and Oswald, representing the realist, though, written in ordinary language being the work of a realist, are very informative and revolutionary at the time. Oswald's view attacks the philosophical basis of marriage, both on practical and moral reasons. Even in their time, getting into marriage requires a lot, in terms of money and effort. Mr. Manders was shocked by Oswald's revelation that "a man living with his chidren and his children's mother." The immorality of living together under this regime was denounced by Mr. Manders and labelled this as, "unprincipled conditions known as irregular unions!" Oswald retorted, "would you rather he should repudiate his children's mother?" He further stated, in answer to Mr Manders charged that such union is highly scandalous, "What else are they to do? A poor artist, and a poor girl-it costs a good deal to get married. what else are they to do?" These exchanges offers a lot of informations, where one can draw his own intelligent and independent opinion on the matter. As for me, I have long ago settled this particular issue. Good luck! Oswald.
Ernesto
Thursday, April 10, 2008
Wednesday, April 9, 2008
Opinion on Pastor Mander's character
Krupa
I oppose Mander's because I don't think life about sadness. In his views, desiring happiness and joy in life is against a person's duties. I completely disagree with that.
I oppose Mander's because I don't think life about sadness. In his views, desiring happiness and joy in life is against a person's duties. I completely disagree with that.
Opinion on Mrs. Alving's character
Krupa
So far, I like Act I of Ghost. I kind of disagree with the character of Mrs. Aliving because she only showed the bad side of her husband to her son, Oswald. In my belief, everyone has two sides: a good and a bad. Although she tried to talk to him again in the future about the respect for his father, but unfortunately, it was too late. She should've mentioned regarding this earlier in time or at least at the time when she told Oswald about her husband's crulty. She should've have lightened up both sides of him.
So far, I like Act I of Ghost. I kind of disagree with the character of Mrs. Aliving because she only showed the bad side of her husband to her son, Oswald. In my belief, everyone has two sides: a good and a bad. Although she tried to talk to him again in the future about the respect for his father, but unfortunately, it was too late. She should've mentioned regarding this earlier in time or at least at the time when she told Oswald about her husband's crulty. She should've have lightened up both sides of him.
Mauray C.
This story is very scandalous and ironic. It scandalous in that a memorial of honor is about to take place for a man who was not honorable. A priest is even going to speak at this memorial, only to avoid a scandal.
This story is also ironic because Oswald is trying to touch Regina just as his father Capitain Alving did to Johanna the maid. Could he possibly be turing into a debauched man like his father? I guess in act 2 we will find out.
This story is also ironic because Oswald is trying to touch Regina just as his father Capitain Alving did to Johanna the maid. Could he possibly be turing into a debauched man like his father? I guess in act 2 we will find out.
Mauray C.
Mrs. Alving is a strong woman, being able to stay in a marriage like hers. She had a lot to deal with. She had to keep her son Oswald ignorant of his father's true ways. he also had to make her husband look good in front of everybody. Her husband even tried to seduce the maid a one point. She was like the "man" in the relationship. She had to make all the decisions that was best for her, her reputation, her family, and her family's reputation.
April 9, 2008
Oswald and Regina were the ones that Mrs Alving saw in the conservatory reminding her of the same situation where she caught her husband with Joanna, servant and mother of Regina. This is one of the issues that Ibsen being a realist wants to impart on the audience, the past predetermines the present.
Ernesto
Oswald and Regina were the ones that Mrs Alving saw in the conservatory reminding her of the same situation where she caught her husband with Joanna, servant and mother of Regina. This is one of the issues that Ibsen being a realist wants to impart on the audience, the past predetermines the present.
Ernesto
Tuesday, April 8, 2008
In Response to Hope
I completely agree with you Hope. The conversation between Mrs. Alving and Pastor Manders was a shock! I feel this conversation does show the realism though. Mrs. Alving dealt with a situation that many women deal with on a daily basis. She stayed in an unhappy marriage for the sake of her child, and did what was best for him.
Erica Atiles
Erica Atiles
Ghosts Act I....Hope A.
I find it crazy that for so many years, Mrs. Alving has kept her past with her desceased husband a secret. I dont know if i could've. I wonder if Mrs. Alving feels Oswald is goin to be somewhat like his father with the whole servant thing.
Realism and Act 1 of Ghosts, Atiles.
According to dictionary.com realism can be defined as interest in or concern for the actual or real as distinguished from abstract, speculative, etc. or/and the tendency to view or represent things as they really are. In Act 1 of Ghosts, Henrik Ibsen definitely implements the idea of real life. He only introduced a few characters in act one but realism in prevalent. These characters are dealing with topics such as alcoholism, affairs, religion, scandals and etc.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
